Mattress Reviews By A 25 Year Mattress Expert: Objective Testing And Ratings Of Top Online Mattress Brands

My name is Marc Anderson and I spent 25 years in the trenches as a mattress designer and manufacturer. I learned very fast that most people hate mattress shopping and get frustrated with all of the marketing mumbo jumbo.

Even worse, there’s nothing more terrible than walking into a mattress store and having to choose between 35-40 mattresses that kind of all feel similar.

How do you know if you’re paying too much, or not investing in something that’s going to feel just as good five years from now as it does the day you buy it?

I’ll help you sort through the nonsense and find the best mattress options that won’t be regrettable. I know mattresses from top to bottom.

I’ve tested the web’s top brands, slept on them, and can give you honest reviews that cut to the chase, without the hype.

Here are the five considerations I use to evaluate when I review and test mattresses:

Comfort/Firmness Level:

Mattresses come in a range of firmness levels, which I also equate with comfort, from soft to firm. The ideal firmness depends on personal preference and sleeping style.

Some prefer the plush feel of a soft mattress, while others may find more support and comfort in a firmer option.

About 70% of shoppers seem to be satisfied with mattresses that are “medium”, 20% like “firm”, and 10% prefer something very “soft”. I test for comfort and cush factor using objective techniques.

Pressure/Pain Relief:

A comfortable mattress should distribute body weight evenly and alleviate pressure points, especially around the shoulders, hips, and lower back. Pressure relief is essential for preventing discomfort and pain during sleep.

Side sleepers need a bit more cushiness, back sleepers a bit more firmness. Belly sleepers usuall prefer softer options.

Temperature Regulation:

Temperature plays a vastly significant role in sleep comfort. Mattresses with materials that promote breathability and heat dissipation, such as gel-infused foams or breathable covers, can contribute to a cooler sleep environment.

Hot sleepers often do well with natural latex or coil and foam options (hybrids).

Motion Transfer:

For individuals sharing a bed, a mattress with good motion isolation is crucial. This feature prevents disturbances from a partner’s movements, ensuring a more restful sleep.

Also, solo sleepers may prefer less bouncy mattress options, such as coil mattresses, and opt for all foam options which can dramatically reduce sleep interruption.


A comfortable mattress should maintain its support and comfort over time. Durability is an important factor in ensuring that the mattress continues to meet the user’s comfort preferences for an extended period.

Quick Picks Of Best Mattresses For Presidents Day 2024 I’ve Personally Reviewed

DLX Premier Hybrid Mattress-overall best for comfortRead My Review $500 Off
Saatva Classic Mattress-best luxury innerspringRead My Review$600 Off
photo of the silk & snow mattress from above showing the quilted organic cotton coverSilk & Snow-best organic mattressRead My ReviewPure Latex
Sweetnight Prime Mem Foam Mattress-best pressure reliefRead My Review $613 Off
Puffy Cloud Mattress-best medium firm optionRead My Review$1,350 Off
Nolah Evolution Mattress-best for cooling, pain and side sleepersRead My Review$1,008 Off
Relaxing woman in bathrobe near edge of Logan & Cove Mattress. She is petting a small dog, image is overhead shot offering a comforting view. Pillows and nearby nightstand are also in viewLogan And Cove Hybrid Mattress-best back supportRead My Review$600 Off
Avocado Natural Latex Mattress-best for intimacyRead My Review20% Off

The Only Mattress Review Site Run By A Genuine Mattress Industry Veteran

We build confident mattress shoppers by finding the best mattress options on the web. We offer get-to-the-point mattress reviews and the advice of a genuine expert. We use a 10 data point system to make mattress shopping easier.

A Field Guide To Mattress Shopping-So You Don’t Get Scammed

A page chock full of everything you need to learn to find the best mattress-in about ten minutes flat. We also offer in depth discussions of mattress types, and explanation of common mattress industry practices and designs.

Cups And Balls Mattress Scams And Trickery. We Reveal It All.

After being a mattress manufacturer and designer himself for 25 years, our CEO knows the cheat sheet and playbook of the mattress sales business- and how to help you find the best mattress option.

Is It High Time You Replaced Your Mattress? We Tell You Why And Suggest When.

When is it time to replace your mattress? The amazing benefits of reinventing your sleep program and where to find the best mattress choices. Healthy best practices, too. A checklist to help you decide it’s time.

Mattress Dimensions, Understanding Split King vs. King, Double vs. Full, How To Buy If Solo Sleeper vs. Couple, And Much More.

Our comprehensive guide to mattress measurements. Upgrading your size? We explain your options and best mattress choices.

An Insider’s Guide To The Best Pillows On The Web

A fantastically awesome pillow is critical to a great night’s sleep. From memory foam to gel, to hypoallergenic and latex, our expert found the best options to improve your sleep, and properly support your head and neck so you wake up pain free.

Featured Mattress Reviews By A 25 Year Mattress Industry Expert

I Test The Web’s Popular Mattress Brands Using My Own 10 Point Objective Ranking System, Then Score And Rate Them, So You Don’t Have To

Our featured mattress: check out our comprehensive review of The Sweetnight Prime Memory Foam Mattress and find out why Marc recommends it over store bought memory foam. It scored a prestigious 9.4 out of 10 rating after he put it through rigorous testing. At $949 in queen, and $1149 in king, it’s well made and priced right. And, it’s reversible, with two firmness options.

mattress reviews
The Nolah Natural Latex Mattress Review. Find out why we bestowed upon it our #1 overall “Best Mattress For 2024” rating. Get $600 off with our link. Best mattress for side sleepers, no sinking, pressure relief you won’t believe. Free returns. Lifetime warranty.

Real & Honest Mattress Reviews: No Long Winded Videos, Rambling Content, Graphs, Or Charts

Because we manufactured and designed our own brands for 25 years, we know how to build the perfect mattress.

From foam layers to coils, to organic textiles to adhesives and sewing, we can spot the winners…and the losers. And we’re not afraid to give you our insider advice.

There are over 300 online mattress options to choose from. We’ve reviewed just about all of them, and recommend just a handful. A curated list of great options- from retailers we trust.

mattress buying guide
Get free pillows, free sheets, and a free mattress protector.
The Puffy Royal Mattress

Why this mattress still stands as one of our perennial favorites. See my test results, plus, why it’s good for back and neck pain. Read our Puffy Royal Mattress Review here.

best mattress to buy
Nectar Mattress offers the best memory foam in the industry.
The Nectar Mattress Lineup: For Lower Back Pain, The Industry Standard

Nectar Mattress built its business perfecting memory foam. We’ve reviewed the entire line. For lower back and shoulder pain, they’re hard to beat.

best selling mattress
The Ascend Digital Air Bed System allows you to control soft or firm settings
A Mattress For Couples: Control Your Side Of The Bed!

We reviewed The Habitat Ascend Air Bed System. A digital number style air mattress loaded with features half the price of the leading brand.

Expert Mattress Reviews On The Best Mattress Options On The Web- Not Owned By Mattress Companies…

The Mattress Buyer Guide is operated by an industry expert who spent 25 years as a mattress designer. Marc has scoured the internet to review and recommend the most comfortable and supportive mattresses you can buy. We are the only mattress review site that conducts a “deep review” on every best mattress option we test.

Marc Anderson spent 25 years in the bedding industry as a designer and manufacturer. He created hundreds of mattresses for his own web sites and is respected in the industry.
No annoying charts, graphs, or oddly detailed heat maps, bowling balls, or lab coats. Just the facts, short and sweet, with links to the best deals.

No Nonsense, Just The Best Mattress Reviews

Our trustworthy recommendations of the web’s best affordable mattresses include a carefully chosen list of honest mattress retailers offering top quality mattresses at the best possible prices.

Rather than reviewing and listing hundreds of mattress options to choose from, Marc offers only about 50 brands in his Trusted Dealer program, simply because it’s very difficult to make the cut!

Having just a handful of mattress options makes your mattress shopping experience less miserable and less mystifying. Any suggestions or thoughts? Need any help? Contact us today.

Our proprietary review process involves actually sleeping on and using each mattress we test- for weeks.

After we review them, we place each mattress into a long term reviewer’s home and monitor the process over time- we call this a”deep review”.

We also source reviews on the web, especially Google reviews, and sort them by positive vs. negative experience.

Using owner opinions rather than made up marketing lingo like the content on fake mattress review sites gives you accurate feedback about the web’s most popular mattresses- and brands that might be new to you.

Brands Featured In

Your Attractive Heading